4Coindealers's Feedback Ratings History

Well, I waited several weeks to cool off. But I still feel angry with this seller. Coins sent were not as described and scratched to boot. The seller did offer a return and a small return on the hundreds I spend. Looks like the this person makes a sale, searches around for a like product and sens that junk to you. Anyway, its just my opinion on why it takes so long for this guy to mail out your stuff. Simply stated, this guy is a plain old crook. STAY AWAY!!!!!!

Well, I waited several weeks to cool off. But I still feel angry with this seller. Coins sent were not as described and scratched to boot. The seller did offer a return and a small return on the hundreds I spend. Looks like the this person makes a sale, searches around for a like product and sens that junk to you. Anyway, its just my opinion on why it takes so long for this guy to mail out your stuff. Simply stated, this guy is a plain old crook. STAY AWAY!!!!!!

Well, I waited several weeks to cool off. But I still feel angry with this seller. Coins sent were not as described and scratched to boot. The seller did offer a return and a small return on the hundreds I spend. Looks like the this person makes a sale, searches around for a like product and sens that junk to you. Anyway, its just my opinion on why it takes so long for this guy to mail out your stuff. Simply stated, this guy is a plain old crook. STAY AWAY!!!!!!

This coin he is selling is technically mine. I purchased it on 4/21/2020 for the posted price, $177. At 11 PM that night, 9 hours after paying for it on PayPal, the seller contacted me to tell me that he had made a mistake and the "original price" was $230. He gave me the option to either pay him an additional $53 or cancel the order. I responded telling him that his fictional "original price" was irrelevant, that the coin was already mine because I had already paid, and that he should promptly send me the coin under the terms of the sale that had just occurred. Despite the fact that I specifically said that I would not pay more or cancel the order, he unilaterally cancelled the sale. This was not an acceptable solution because I actually wanted the coin and it was already mine. This seller broke the law by canceling the sale and reposting my coin for a larger price, essentially stealing $53 from me if and when he sells it again. He obviously suffered from some seller

I can not in honesty give a positive feedback. I believe I was lied to by this seller, as I was told by him it took 7 days for my payment to clear. When I doublechecked the day following purchase, USA CoinBook showed item payed for awaiting shipment. PayPal showed the same. In reviewing his feedback yes he has a high positive, but I tend t believe the negative responses. The one thing good I will say for him was he did offer full refund, I declined at that time as this is a coin I’m in need of for a client. I would be very careful doing business with this so called dealer.

I did get coins finally, after 26 days. coins look nice as described. I ordered march 1st, receiver march 26th. paid on paypal right away, order was just over 650 for 3 coins. they did reply to message saying they were busy. After reading other feedback of very late and no delivery, I didn't any longer feel comfortable with stranger, giving them $650 and waiting 26 days for delivery. Most online deliverys are much quicker. I wouldn't recommend the wait to anyone.

I did get coins finally, after 26 days. coins look nice as described. I ordered march 1st, receiver march 26th. paid on paypal right away, order was just over 650 for 3 coins. they did reply to message saying they were busy. After reading other feedback of very late and no delivery, I didn't any longer feel comfortable with stranger, giving them $650 and waiting 26 days for delivery. Most online deliverys are much quicker. I wouldn't recommend the wait to anyone.

I did get coins finally, after 26 days. coins look nice as described. I ordered march 1st, receiver march 26th. paid on paypal right away, order was just over 650 for 3 coins. they did reply to message saying they were busy. After reading other feedback of very late and no delivery, I didn't any longer feel comfortable with stranger, giving them $650 and waiting 26 days for delivery. Most online deliverys are much quicker. I wouldn't recommend the wait to anyone.

I debated about whether to leave neutral or negative feedback on this order, as I like giving people the benefit of doubt. After reading 46 neutral feedback responses and 15 negative feedback responses on this seller that all pertain to my complaint, however, it seems this is the only place my remarks belong. I ordered three Walking Liberty half dollars on 7/16/2018. They did not ship until 7/24/2018 and I did not receive them until 7/26/2018. Why the eight-day delay from order/payment to shipment? It is sad to see what is supposed to be a reputable coin dealer who has no regard for customer service, and seemingly does not care about the numerous neutral and negative remarks it's received (all dealing with slow delivery or NO delivery), as it has clearly made no effort to improve. This is not the first time I've had a delayed delivery from this seller, either (three weeks to receive a Trade Dollar in 2015). It's a shame, because the coins were beautiful in both instances...

I debated about whether to leave neutral or negative feedback on this order, as I like giving people the benefit of doubt. After reading 46 neutral feedback responses and 15 negative feedback responses on this seller that all pertain to my complaint, however, it seems this is the only place my remarks belong. I ordered three Walking Liberty half dollars on 7/16/2018. They did not ship until 7/24/2018 and I did not receive them until 7/26/2018. Why the eight-day delay from order/payment to shipment? It is sad to see what is supposed to be a reputable coin dealer who has no regard for customer service, and seemingly does not care about the numerous neutral and negative remarks it's received (all dealing with slow delivery or NO delivery), as it has clearly made no effort to improve. This is not the first time I've had a delayed delivery from this seller, either (three weeks to receive a Trade Dollar in 2015). It's a shame, because the coins were beautiful in both instances...

I debated about whether to leave neutral or negative feedback on this order, as I like giving people the benefit of doubt. After reading 46 neutral feedback responses and 15 negative feedback responses on this seller that all pertain to my complaint, however, it seems this is the only place my remarks belong. I ordered three Walking Liberty half dollars on 7/16/2018. They did not ship until 7/24/2018 and I did not receive them until 7/26/2018. Why the eight-day delay from order/payment to shipment? It is sad to see what is supposed to be a reputable coin dealer who has no regard for customer service, and seemingly does not care about the numerous neutral and negative remarks it's received (all dealing with slow delivery or NO delivery), as it has clearly made no effort to improve. This is not the first time I've had a delayed delivery from this seller, either (three weeks to receive a Trade Dollar in 2015). It's a shame, because the coins were beautiful in both instances...

I have not received confirmation that orders: 34430 and 34539 have not shipped although I made payment some time ago. What is happening?

Coin wasn't as advertised. Coin had been cleaned both obverse and reverse was only worth the value of silver now. He asked if he returned eight dollars that would be ok. Rather than packing and shipping it back I agreeded. Never heard from them again and never reibursed me the eight dollars. Thinking about sending it back and canceling payment with PayPal. I would have to have a third party video me putting it in envelope and mailing it. Then submit that to PayPal with cancellation.

What happen to the Buffalo Nickels the I Buy. Two Invoices are 22732 and 22620? What Happen. thank you pantillon

Well . . . it's been more than two weeks and still no coin. I'm getting concerned.

I purchased a coin on December 28, 2016 and now January 13, 2017 I have had to file a claim with PayPal because the coin has not shipped and the seller will not respond to messages. I should have reviewed his feedback better. almost all of the positives are AUTOMATED feedback. This guy is a scum bag!

slow on deliver, and the coin is not the one that is shown on the listing after I order I seen where it is listed that its not the coin shown, but I would thank that it would be close to it. but the one I received is not close to it the coin has a big cut across the chest of the eagle and the chest is flat on the back and a big cut on the right side on the front of the coin its listed at a XF 1884-S Morgan Dollar but its under that listing to me with out the big cuts marks on the front and revers it would be close , I have looked at a lot of listings on ebay and this site and the ones that our listed to be XF r in better shape ! I would say that this coin is over rated by fare

BEWARE. Nice enough coin sent, but was not the coin I thought I was buying. Not at all like the coin in the photo. Seller does state a disclaimer saying that photo is only representative of the coin shown, but I did not see that before I purchased. My mistake. Don't make the same mistake. I do not like buying coins sight unseen, therefore I will NOT be buying from this dealer ever again. This kind of selling is not in the best interest of coin-collecting, but only in the best interest of the seller. Only the seller controls the option of what you will receive. Kind of like ordering a red GT Mustang from Ford, and getting a blue six-cylinder. I will keep the coin to avoid having to pay the 10% restocking fee and return postage...again, all to the seller's benefit. Seller wins whether I keep it or not. I ended up with a coin I would not have necessarily bought. Sleazy deal. NOT happy at all.

Coins received were cleaned and not very nice. Lower grade than what was pictured in original posting. The old bait and switch trick. Got a refund, but took a week after they received the coins and had to remind them to send refund. Beware

Coins received were cleaned and not very nice. Lower grade than what was pictured in original posting. The old bait and switch trick. Got a refund, but took a week after they received the coins and had to remind them to send refund. Beware

Coin took over three weeks to receive and feedback was poor.

Coin took over three weeks to receive and feedback was poor.

Coin took over three weeks to receive and feedback was poor.

CAVEAT EMPTOR! This seller ships very, very slow. My coins took almost three weeks to arrive, and only shipped after I threatened legal action. I paid immediately using PayPal. All other sellers that I purchased from on USACoin Book ship fast, and I receive my coins in 3 to 5 days. I don't understand why this seller can not do the same. Too bad, because he has some nice coins that I would very much like to add to my collection, however, I don't want to risk losing money. Therefore Caveat Emptor - buyer beware!

CAVEAT EMPTOR! This seller ships very, very slow. My coins took almost three weeks to arrive, and only shipped after I threatened legal action. I paid immediately using PayPal. All other sellers that I purchased from on USACoin Book ship fast, and I receive my coins in 3 to 5 days. I don't understand why this seller can not do the same. Too bad, because he has some nice coins that I would very much like to add to my collection, however, I don't want to risk losing money. Therefore Caveat Emptor - buyer beware!