1. USA Coin Book
  2. Nickels
  3. Buffalo
  4. 1916-P

For Sale 77Collection 68

77 items found

1916 P Buffalo Nickel
$2.95
Seller: Kropasj
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 buffalo nickel in VERY FINE condition
$7.95
Free Shipping
Seller: Rewscoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: VERY FINE
1916 buffalo nickel with FINE details
$5.45
Free Shipping
Seller: Rewscoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: FINE
1916 Buffalo Nickel, FS-402, 2 Feathers, PCGS MS-63
$479.00
Seller: tipsico
Certification Agency: PCGS
Certification Number: 53954788
Condition: MS-63
1916 buffalo nickel in VERY FINE condition
$9.45
Free Shipping
Seller: Rewscoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: VERY FINE
1916 buffalo nickel in FINE condition
$5.95
Free Shipping
Seller: Rewscoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: FINE
1916 Buffalo Nickel, FS-402 2 Feathers, CACG MS-61, Partial Designers Initial
$529.00
Seller: tipsico
Certification Agency: CACG
Certification Number: 811283136
Condition: MS-61
1916-P Buffalo Nickel
$4.95
Make An Offer or Best Offer
Free Shipping
Seller: edgch
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: F
1916-P Buffalo Nickel
$15.00
Seller: Schultzierock
Certification Agency: Other
Condition: VF
1916 Buffalo Nickel XF
$10.00
Seller: Nashuacoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: XF
1916-P Buffalo Nickel
$6.00
Seller: Schultzierock
Certification Agency: Other
Condition: Fine
1916 Buffalo Nickel, XF (8781)
$15.00
Seller: MidMichiganCoin
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: VF
1916-P Buffalo Nickel
$6.00
Seller: mMm1901
Certification Agency: Other
Condition: Fine
1916-P Grades Very Good Buffalo Nickel Coin ( 400-59 )
$9.00
Make An Offer or Best Offer
Seller: stephen11
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 Buffalo Nickel (41-399)
$5.40
Seller: TylerCoinCo2019
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 Buffalo Nickel (40-399)
$4.00
Seller: TylerCoinCo2019
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Buffalo Nickel 1916
$13.00
Seller: coinhub
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 P Extra Fine Buffalo Nickel ( 216-Q )
$6.00
Make An Offer or Best Offer
Seller: stephen11
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 buffalo nickel in FINE condition
$5.95
Free Shipping
Seller: Rewscoins
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: FINE
1916 P Buffalo Nickel
$10.95
Seller: bdemars-coin-store
Certification Agency: Other
Certification Number: 001630
Condition: Very Fine
no image available
1916 P Buffalo Nickel Circulated
$11.00
Seller: Landseagoods
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
no image available
1916 Indian Head Nickel circulated P
$10.00
Make An Offer or Best Offer
Seller: Landseagoods
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated, Original BU Coin 1119-16
$95.00
Seller: tipsico
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 Buffalo Nickel, Choice Uncirculated 1119-17
$80.00
Seller: tipsico
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
1916 P Buffalo Nickel
$18.50
Seller: blstevens
Certification Agency: Raw / Unspecified
Condition: average circulated



Buy and Sell on USA Coin Book

Open a free Account Sign In Sell Coins: List coins for sale Recently sold items on USA Coin Book Top Coin Dealers and Sellers

Site Information

Coin Encyclopedia About Us Contact Us Fee Information User Agreement Privacy Policy Your Privacy Choices Updates, Upgrades and News (2/7/2026) Scam Alerts (6/17/2025)

Follow USA Coin Book

USA Coin Book on Facebook Facebook USA Coin Book on Twitter / X Twitter USA Coin Book on LinkedIn Linkedin

Currency Converter

Switch View

© 2010 - 2026 USA Coin Book. All Rights Reserved.