ThePennyCollector's Feedback Ratings History

ThePennyCollector
Contact   contact member
Member Since: Jan 23 2022 07:57 PM CST
Last Login Activity: Dec 12 2023 02:36 PM CST


Positive 22As Buyer 22Given to Others 22
Given To: mainewoods ( 357 ) - August 18 2023 - 05:28 PM CDT
Very nice coin
Given To: stephen11 ( 9764 ) - February 6 2023 - 07:03 PM CST
Nice coin for my collection
Given To: edgch ( 2537 ) - February 5 2023 - 05:38 PM CST
Coin had a full date, back was more worn than the one in the picture, but it's my first shield nickel, so no complaints here.
Given To: Wizardman ( 937 ) - January 30 2023 - 08:23 PM CST
Great coin, my first standing liberty quarter!
Given To: Paul7554 ( 435 ) - January 19 2023 - 10:35 AM CST
This coin didn't ship for 16 days before I noticed, we exchanged many emails, and after almost a month, the coin arrived (shipping was quick though). I couldn't understand the writing on the note, save for a few words (would love to know the full letter.) and the five layers of packaging made it hard, yet fun, to retrieve the coin. Got an additional 2 BU pennies to make up for the delay. The coin itself was okay, but not quite as shiny as the picture showed. Overall, the purchase had a few bumps, but it got delivered in the end. Would buy from this seller again.

Reply by Paul7554: I am sorry for my mix up. Even though I've been selling through this site for over 6 months I'm not exactly sure how payment works and when to ship because I have been burned a couple of times. Bless you for your patience and understanding. Please check the diagnostics on the coin that it is the one pictured. I try my best to have the coin photographed as much as possible showing exactly how it will look in person but I'm working on it. Paul.
Given To: stephen11 ( 9764 ) - January 5 2023 - 05:55 PM CST
Nice filler.
Given To: Jnatalizio ( 159 ) - January 5 2023 - 05:52 PM CST
Got three 30s, one '27, and 2 teens, also got 2 steel. wasn't too bad.
Given To: stephen11 ( 9764 ) - November 20 2022 - 06:37 PM CST
Given To: bejemcoins ( 1103 ) - May 26 2022 - 06:52 PM CDT
Still have not recieved the coins after 13 days, and there is no tracking number, so I can't figure out where the package is. It said the coins had been shipped as long as 5 days ago, however, they still have not arrived. I will not jump to conclusions, but I will be asking for a refund.
Given To: bejemcoins ( 1103 ) - May 26 2022 - 06:52 PM CDT
Still have not recieved the coins after 13 days, and there is no tracking number, so I can't figure out where the package is. It said the coins had been shipped as long as 5 days ago, however, they still have not arrived. I will not jump to conclusions, but I will be asking for a refund.
Given To: 1909S ( 4093 ) - May 26 2022 - 06:47 PM CDT
Another BU for my collection!
Given To: 1909S ( 4093 ) - May 26 2022 - 06:47 PM CDT
😊
Given To: 1909S ( 4093 ) - May 26 2022 - 06:47 PM CDT
Was a bit lower of a grade than I expected, but it looks okay.
Given To: TreasureCoins44 ( 1843 ) - May 5 2022 - 06:43 PM CDT
Three holes in my collection filled in!

Reply by TreasureCoins44: 🌟 GREAT PERSON AND THE BEST TO DEAL WITH ON USA COIN BOOK THAT YOU’LL FIND 🌟
Given To: edgch ( 2537 ) - April 24 2022 - 04:20 PM CDT
Great looking coin, thanks!
Given To: OLDIES4SALE2007 ( 4994 ) - April 24 2022 - 04:17 PM CDT
Great looking coin, another BU for my collection. Thanks!
Given To: OLDIES4SALE2007 ( 4994 ) - April 24 2022 - 04:17 PM CDT
Realized I didn’t need this coin after I ordered it, but at least it’s in better grade than my old one. (No pun intended) Thanks for the coin.
Given To: stephen11 ( 9764 ) - April 6 2022 - 09:51 PM CDT
Another BU for my collection!
Given To: waltsgarage51 ( 55 ) - March 12 2022 - 11:22 PM CST
Order recieved in 4 days 23 hours 45 minutes, which was about two days after the said delivery time. But then again, I do live in Alaska, so that's kind of expected. The 1920-S (VG-08) cost a little more than it's worth, as well as the 1931-S (VF-30). Overall, purchase was satisfactory.
Given To: waltsgarage51 ( 55 ) - March 12 2022 - 11:22 PM CST
Order recieved in 4 days 23 hours 45 minutes, which was about two days after the said delivery time. But then again, I do live in Alaska, so that's kind of expected. The 1920-S (VG-08) cost a little more than it's worth, as well as the 1931-S (VF-30). Overall, purchase was satisfactory.
Given To: johnsonp11 ( 247 ) - February 18 2022 - 10:38 PM CST
Given To: Adventurecoins ( 1473 ) - January 29 2022 - 02:32 PM CST
I got a good amount of 20s, lots of 30s (almost all of them were 1935-37) and 3 extras. No teens, but I got a lot of fillers, so that's fine, I guess. I definitely got my money's worth, would buy from this seller again.